~
photographer unknown
Schuller insisted that "by definition there is no such thing as 'Third Stream Jazz'".
He noted that while purists on both sides of
Third Stream
objected to tainting their favorite music with the other, more strenuous
objections were typically made by jazz musicians who felt such efforts
were "an assault on their traditions." Schuller wrote that "by
designating the music as a 'separate, Third Stream,' the other two
mainstreams could go about their way unaffected by the attempts at
fusion."
Because
Third Stream draws on classical as much as jazz, it is
generally required that composers and performers be proficient in both
genres.
Critics argued that Third Stream—by drawing on two very different
styles—dilutes the power of each in combining them. Others reject such
notions, and consider
Third Stream an interesting musical development.
In 1981, Schuller offered a list of "What Third Stream is not":
- It is not jazz with strings.
- It is not jazz played on 'classical' instruments.
- It is not classical music played by jazz players.
- It is not inserting a bit of Ravel or Schoenberg between be-bop changes—nor the reverse.
- It is not jazz in fugal form.
- It is not a fugue played by jazz players.
- It is not designed to do away with jazz or classical music; it is
just another option amongst many for today’s creative musicians.
Attempts to integrate jazz and classical music began in the early 1900s
almost as soon as the former became recognised as a distinct style of
music. Some
ragtime music drew upon classical music, and symphonic pieces such as
Rhapsody In Blue (1924) (
link below), by
George Gershwin, blended jazz and symphonic music. The piece
La création du monde by French composer
Darius Milhaud includes jazz-inspired elements, including a jazz fugue.
Igor Stravinsky drew upon jazz for several compositions, such as
Ragtime,
Piano-Rag-Music and the
Ebony Concerto (the last composed for jazz clarinetist
Woody Herman and his orchestra in 1945) (
link below). Other notable composers who utilized jazz elements in at least a few compositions include
Maurice Ravel,
Bohuslav Martinů,
Paul Hindemith,
William Grant Still,
George Antheil,
Aaron Copland,
Ernst Krenek,
Kurt Weill,
Dmitri Shostakovich,
Morton Gould, and
Leonard Bernstein. Though few of these examples can be strictly classified as
Third Stream as they do not involve
improvisation, they do demonstrate that there was widespread mutual interest and appreciation between the jazz and classical traditions.
The work of
Duke Ellington has often been recognized as being among the early efforts to
blend the elements associated with both genres. His music has been
described as sharing characteristics with that of classical composers
such as
Delius,
Debussy, and
Ravel, particularly in impressionistic mood pieces such as
Mood Indigo (
link below),
Dusk, and
Reflections in D, as well as in more extended composed
works such as
Creole Rhapsody,
Reminiscing in Tempo and
The
Tattooed Bride. These tendencies were also shared by his frequent
co-composer
Billy Strayhorn.
KFG Radio Studio - November 3, 1954
photographer unknown
The Afro-British composer
Reginald Foresythe was one of the first
musicians to combine the two genres from the early 1930s
onwards. Branding his style "The New Music", his compositions, such as
Garden of Weed,
Serenade for a Wealthy Widow and the Bach-influenced
Dodging A Divorcee were received well by critics but poorly by the
British public, who were baffled by its radical style. However,
Foresythe's music found a warmer welcome in America, particularly among black musicians, resulting in collaborations with
Duke Ellington,
Earl Hines and
Benny Goodman.
photographer unknown
photographer unknown
Another important jazz-classical fusion was
Interlude in B-flat by
Artie Shaw recorded in 1935 with the most unusual ensemble
of a string quartet, a jazz rhythm section, and Shaw on
clarinet and
saxophone (
link below).
Much of the
Charles Mingus
oeuvre before and after the coining of the term "Third Stream"
parallels Schuller's idea. Indeed, the title of Mingus' two-part album
Jazzical Moods
(1955), a blend of "jazz" and "classical," may have helped to inspire
Schuller; the two men were also friends. The immense final work,
Epitaph, by Mingus was edited and premiered at
Lincoln Center in 1989 by Schuller.
photographer unknown
Despite the early examples noted above, critic
Scott Yanow writes, "it was not until the mid-to-late '50s that more serious experiments began to take place.
Schuller,
J. J. Johnson,
John Lewis and
Bill Russo were some of the more significant composers attempting to bridge the gap between jazz and classical music."
A great example of this is the
John Lewis composition for the 1961 production for the
San Francisco Ballet,
Original Sin, which I will never forget seeing for both the music and the dancing. Produced under the direction of
Lew Christensen,
it featured Adam and Eve in flesh-tone body tights with a brilliant
lighting design that made them appear nude. Of course, 10 years later,
dancers actually DID dance nude in ballet. Somehow, the earlier
incarnation seemed more stimulating; funny how that works.
Yanow also suggests that the impact of
Third Stream music was blunted by the rise of
free jazz in the late 1950s, which overtook Third Stream as the leading development in jazz. Schuller was heavily involved with the
Columbia Records LPs
Music For Brass (1957) and
Modern Jazz Concert (1958), later re-issued to become what is known as the recording
Birth Of The Third Stream (now as CD). The recording greatly helped to push the concept and legitimacy of the style and approach to this music.
Jazz composer and producer
Teo Macero, who went on to produce
Miles Davis and
Dave Brubeck, was influenced by the
Third Stream movement. Other notable examples of the style include Lewis's
Modern Jazz Quartet and solo efforts,
Teddy Charles,
Don Ellis,
Gil Evans,
Bill Russo,
George Russell, Brubeck and his brother,
Howard Brubeck,
Jacques Loussier and his
Play Bach Trio,
Jimmy Giuffre,
Toshiko Akiyoshi,
David Amram,
Ran Blake,
David Baker, and
Bob Graettinger. Lewis was instrumental in arranging for
Atlantic Records to record Schuller's
Jazz Abstractions in 1960 featuring
Jim Hall,
Ornette Coleman,
Eric Dolphy and
Bill Evans. Many
free jazz composers and performers, such as
Cecil Taylor,
Anthony Braxton,
Yitzhak Yedid, the band
Oregon, and
Sun Ra, were also influenced by the Third Stream school.
Fred Tompkins,
has forged a style which seems to enjoy the benefits of fully notated
composition, while also capturing the strong, propulsive essence of
jazz. His early works were often accompanied by the drumming of
Elvin Jones and then by other drummers from New York or St. Louis.
photographer unknown
photographer unknown
Styrous® ~ Friday, August 25. 2017